Systematic review of current executive function measures in adults with and without cognitive impairments
- Pickens, S., Ostwald, S. K., Murphy-Pace, K., and Bergstrom, N.
- BACKGROUND: Executive function pertains to higher cognitive processes historically linked to frontal lobes. Several measures are available to screen for executive function; however, no gold standard exists. The difficulty in assessing executive function is the existence of its many subsets.
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the psychometric properties of executive function measures and determine the most effective measure(s) through a systematic review of the literature.
SEARCH STRATEGY: The search strategy utilised a comprehensive literature review of articles written in the English language published from January 2003 to September 2009. The following electronic databases were searched: SCOPUS, PUBMED, Medline Ovid, PsychArticles and CINAHL Plus. Initial key words used were 'executive function', 'measures', 'reliability' and 'validity' followed by the addition of 'traumatic brain injury'. The initial search elicited 226 articles, of which 28 were retrieved. After further exclusion 19 were included in the review.
RESULTS: Eight measures underwent factor analysis and 18 underwent various forms of reliability and/or validity testing. Factor analysis showed different aspects of executive functions. According to preset evaluation criteria, only the Test of Practical Judgment performed all of the recommended reliability and validity testing. REVIEWER'S
CONCLUSION: Of the recently developed measures, several show promise for future use yet further validity and reliability testing is warranted. Future tool development should measure all subsets of executive function rather than only a few and include the recommended components of reliability and validity testing
- PM:21199379; http://graphics.tx.ovid.com/ovftpdfs/FPDDNCOBFHPIGD00/fs046/ovft/live/gv025/01258363/01258363-201009000-00002.pdf
- Int J Evid.Based.Healthc.
- Publication year:
- Functional status:
- Cognitive/mental functioning
- Adults (18-65)
- Mental and behavioural disorders and related symptoms
Symptoms, signs and abnormal clinical and laboratory findings, not elsewhere classified
- PRO / non-PRO:
- Non-patient Reported Outcome
Patient Reported Outcome
- Type of measurement instrument:
- 1 - Questionnaires
4 - Performance-based tests
6 - Clinical rating scales
7 - Observations
- 3CL - Cognitive Change Checklist
ACED - Assessment of Capacity for Everyday Decision Making
BATCH - Behavioral Assessment Tool for Cognition and Higher function
BDS-EV - Behavioral Dyscontrol Scale-Electronic Version
CANS-MCI - Computer-Administered Neuropsychological Screen for Mild Cognitive Impairment
CET - Cognitive Estimation Test
COWAT - Controlled Oral Word Association Test;
D-KEFS - Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System (versions: D-KEFS - Design Fluency Test)
EF Battery - Executive Function Battery (SCWT (Stroop Color-Word Test); WCST (Wisconsin Card Sorting Test); TMT (Trails Making Test); CFL (Letter Fluency); CAT (Category Fluency))
EFPT - Executive Function Performance Test
EPFS - Executive Personal Finance Scale
FAVRES - Functional Assessment of Verbal Reasoning and Executive Strategies
NTB - Neuropsychological Test Battery
PGNG-3 - Parametric Go/No-Go Test
RNG - Random Number Generator task
TASIT - The Awareness of Social Inference Test
Toglia's Deductive Reasoning Test
TOP-J - Test Of Practical Judgement